Department O Friday Culinary judging at the Logan County Fair

[August 11, 2026]  At the Logan County Fair Friday morning, there was a lot of sweetness as the second portion of the Department O Dairy and Culinary judging took place. The cake portion of the judging is especially significant because the winners of the individual cake categories are the first to participate in Sunday’s Logan County Cake Classic. This bake-off competition produces between six and eight incredibly delicious cakes that will then be auctioned off to the highest bidder.

Department O Friday Culinary judging at the Logan County Fair is run by superintendents Janet Estill and Marcia Greenslate along with their committee of Ron Estill and Linda McCuan.

Brenda Silano, who retired several years ago after teaching at Lincoln Community High School for 24 years, returned as judge. In her culinary classes, her students baked many cakes and would also make treats and snacks they would sell to other students.

As Silano judged various items, she made comments such as smooth top, flavor was excellent and don’t want it to stick to your teeth.

The first class was peanut clusters. First place in this category was Rose Harrold followed by Eva Sanders in second place, Linda L. Aper in third place and Brooke Harnacke in fourth place.

In the peanut brittle category, Carlene Carter won first place followed by Darlene Crider in second place.

Winner of the fudge without marshmallows category was Brooke Harnacke with Bev Hinkle placing second, Kathleen Buse placing third and Darlene Crider placing fourth.

The caramel category was small with just two participants. Patty Huffer placed first followed by Rose Harrold in second.

Divinity was another small class with just one entry by Carlene Carter.

Another category with one entry was caramel corn made by Brooke Harnacke.

For fudge with marshmallows, Kathleen Buse took first followed by Brooke Harnacke in second place and Darlene Crider in third place.

The pretzel treats category was won by Patty Huffer followed by Brooke Harnacke in second place, Peggy Sanders in third place and Hannah Meece in fourth place.

The trail mix winners were Brooke Harnacke in first, John P. Sandel in second, Hannah Meece in third and Carlene Crider in fourth

The no bake cereal treat winner was Patty Huffer followed by Carlene Carter in second place, Brooke Harnacke in third place and Bev Hinkle in fourth place.

[to top of second column]

 

Once the categories were concluded, Silano chose the best of the best in the candy category. There was a best of show in candy, best of show snack foods and best of show cakes. Each best of show winner would receive a purple rosette ribbon.

The final judging was for best of show overall, with the rosette winners being put up against each other to choose the very best of the day.

Best of show for both candy and snack foods went to Patty Huffer.

With those categories concluded, it was time to move on to cakes. There were fewer entries than previous years. In fact, for German sweet chocolate and red velvet, there were no entries.

The first category was chocolate cake with chocolate frosting with first place being awarded to Jeanne Runyon.

For yellow butter cake with chocolate frosting, Jamie Wibben placed first.

White butter with white frosting had two entries. Rose Harrold took first followed by Hannah Meece in second.

Baker’s choice winner was Peggy Sanders. Her cake had strawberry filling and pink icing.

Placing first in the angel food cake category was Jeanne Runyon.

Jeanne Runyon also won first place for her chiffon cake. Silano said chiffon cakes have an interesting history. It was first made in 1927 by a man named Harry Baker, who for many years kept the recipe secret. The texture was similar to angel food, but different ingredients were used. Later Baker sold the recipe to General Mills. Some called it the first new cake in 100 years.

Best of show overall was Rose Harrold.

All the cake category winners will be eligible to compete on Sunday at the Cake Classic with the delicious cakes lovingly prepared for the Logan County Fair Fundraiser Auction.

Harrold will be baking her white butter cake in the cake classic on Sunday.

For baker’s choice, Peggy Sanders will bake a chocolate gingerbread cake.

Jeanne Runyon will be baking one of the cakes for which she won first place.

Department O Friday Culinary judging photo slideshow

[Angela Reiners]


 

Back to top