MAXimizing Life
with Maxine McQueen

Bagna calda and oyster stew review

[January 03, 2026]

“New Year’s is a harmless annual institution, of no particular use to anybody save as a scapegoat for promiscuous drunks, and friendly calls and humbug resolutions.” “And now we welcome the new year. Full of things that have never been. Be at war with your vices, at peace with your neighbors, and let every new year find you a better man.” Mark Twain.

As 2025 comes to an end many of us applaud its exit, some of us would like to put the brakes on it and savor it longer, but in the end 2026 arrives and delivers to us all it has to offer.

I remember back to the celebrations of New Year’s Eve past. For some reason, many of them were spent with someone in the family sick in bed. Christmas was too merry or too demanding, and a parent, child, or sibling would succumb to said adversity. It seemed as if it was the norm of the first decade of Mac’s and my marriage. I would just automatically know to have chicken noodle soup on the stove, and board games for those pouting about having to stay home. Usually, the culprit was Mac himself. He’d overdo during the season and surrender to the bed and the boys, and I would happily have our own party. We would binge on watching TV, playing games, and eating ourselves silly.

Now that I’m older the endless parties, and driving in the Illinois New Year’s Eve night and weather is beyond me. However, the eating is not! Yay!

When I still lived at home Mother would make Dad oyster stew for every New Year’s Eve. How awful. Just looking at oysters is disgusting. They look like great big ole snot gurgling. I said such to my father one time and was sent from the table for the rest of the evening. Notice the “one time” comment. Mother made me try the stew another year, saying it tasted better than it looked. I eyed the creamy broth, the butter floating on top, the dark snotty blobs and the dear face of my momma. I took a big spoonful and downed it for her. My reaction was such that I was yet again banned from the table by Dad.

The only quote by Woody Allen that I agree with is, “I will not eat oysters. I want my food dead. Not sick. Not wounded. Dead.”

Mom was fair. She always had a pot of her delicious chili simmering alongside Dad’s oyster stew. Our only concession was that we had to eat oyster crackers in our chili the few times that Dad required his oyster stew. That was an easy compromise. I just learned not to look at Dad’s stew and to try not to breathe in oyster fumes. For those of you who love the concoction of mucus and cream, may God bless you richly. This farm girl cannot get with that program.

Amazing Facts Home…” Oysters can change their gender multiple times during their life.” Hmmm, that’s thought provoking. “They’re one of the few animals that humans eat both raw and alive.” Not this human. “Oysters have been consumed by humans for at least 4,000 years.” Facts are stranger than fiction. “Ostrea-phobia is the fear of oysters.” Yep….I’m going to add that to my medical list of allergies and anxieties.

[to top of second column]

At one time, our shop was in the middle of an old strip mall. We were next door to Cattani’s Rental Equipment. Every New Year’s Eve they would make enough Bagna Cauda to feed the town. The first year they did this, I turned my Scot/Irish farmer’s nose up in disgust and couldn’t imagine trying it. My Mac, on the other hand, had no qualms in leaving our shop in my hands and diving headfirst into the Bagna Cauda bowl. Now, for those of you who don’t know…..this dish is make of garlic, anchovies, garlic, butter, garlic, and sometimes cream. Bagna Cauda is Italian for “hot bath”. It did seem Mac took a bath in it. Once you eat this, your body excretes it out your every pore for the next three weeks. It is disgusting. My eyes teared up whenever he came near. He absolutely reeked. He. Didn’t. Care.

The next year, Cattani’s made an even bigger batch. My Mac’s mouth was watering all morning as it heated and brewed. In self-defense I marched over hand in hand with him to try it. It’s kept over a hot flame to keep it warm as you dip fresh vegetables or thick fresh bread into it. You can, as I said, use cream or not. My theory is if you use that poundage of butter, what’s the calories of a gallon of cream? I. Was. Pathetic. I couldn’t get enough of it. People passing on the street two blocks away commented about the smell. It lingered in Cattani’s shop for weeks. It stuck on us as Flick’s tongue stuck on the frozen flagpole after being triple dog dared in “A Christmas Story.” Garlic, anchovies, butter, calibrating fluid, and diesel fuel permeated the air for a month. The stench was worth it. We were used to the latter as we worked with diesel. It just added to the ambiance of our establishment.

Black-eyed peas on New Year’s Day is a time-honored tradition served with cornbread. Mom took this and made it her own ritual using ham and beans with cornbread. Yum! Yum! She’d buy the dry Great Northern beans and have me search through them for any rocks and debris. Once declared safe, we’d soak them in water overnight and cook them all day. It. Was. Delicious. The saltiness of the ham, the creamy smooth texture of the beans, the cornbread doused in Karo syrup was intoxicating. What a meal! My thought is it is a much better way to start a year. Almost made up for ending the previous night with oyster stew. Almost.

“Celebrate endings…for they precede new beginnings” Jonathan Lockwood Huie


L. Maxine McQueen may be contacted at maxmac.1@juno.com

 

< Recent features

Back to top